Bildnachweis: supparsorn für Getty Images (via Canva pro)
What are India's strengths and weaknesses as a production location compared to China?
India and China are equally important economic powers in Asia. High populations and lower wages make both countries attractive production locations for multinational companies.
India has improved its infrastructure recently with a modernized transport network, while China has a mature infrastructure with better access to rail and airport facilities. In terms of the quality of the labor force, China has more experience and a greater supply of skilled labor, especially in technical fields, while India has fewer skilled workers but at the same time offers easier access to young and talented workers who can be trained.
Overall, both countries have unique strengths and weaknesses that need to be considered by companies entering the market.
When it comes to technically demanding tasks, China may turn out to be a better choice. However, when it comes to cost savings via lower-wage tiers, India may be the better option.
India as a manufacturing location: Strengths
India has over 1.3 billion people, of which over 800 million are under 35 years of age and have an ever-growing labor demand. This provides a great opportunity for companies to expand in India and employ more workers. Wages in India are significantly lower than in China, which makes it attractive for companies to move their production to India. The Indian government has also introduced tax benefits for companies that can help reduce costs even further. In addition, India also offers investment allowances and financial aid to make it easier for companies to gain a foothold in the country.
Infrastructural development is also a plus, as recently the Indian government has made significant investments in infrastructure development to make it easier for businesses to set up shop in the country and enter new markets. One of the most important projects was the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST), intended to simplify the tax structure and better integrate different states in the country.
The Indian market has also proven to be innovative and offers many opportunities for companies to engage in socially responsible activities and implement sustainable business processes. With the right strategies and commitment, companies can therefore succeed in gaining advantages from the competition with China while continuing to drive their commitment to sustainability and social responsibility.
Weaknesses of India as a production location compared to China
India has some major weaknesses even when compared to China. One of the biggest disadvantages for companies manufacturing in India is transport and logistics. There is a lack of roads, railways, and ports, which makes it difficult to transport materials. This increases the price of goods and services, significantly.
Another disadvantage is that India does not have a comprehensive platform for international trade compared to China. Therefore, companies in India often have to deal with more bureaucracy than their competitors in China. Again, costs may increase significantly. In addition, India does not have robust political stability like China, which often deters investors.
Therefore, India is probably not the first country for foreign investors who prefer security. About tax matters, the same is true: there are many tax systems and rules in India, which can make investment more challenging.
India: An investment in the future
Overall, it is clear that China currently still scores with robust infrastructure, political stability, a more comprehensive trading platform, and larger markets. But India is catching up, which the automotive industry has also recognized. Meanwhile, almost all major car manufacturers have set up production facilities in India, which will certainly have a positive impact on the infrastructure and the market situation in the future.
Entering India as a production location is therefore worthwhile - especially because of the country's potential as an innovation driver and in financial and ecological-social areas.